Home Services Team CareersBlog Book a meeting

I Stopped Making Cold Calls. Here's What I Learned About Sales Coaching

Making prospecting calls is one thing. Helping a team get better at them is another.

Article illustration, The Sales Diaries, Eliot Nacasch

Welcome to the first edition of The Sales Diaries.

For this first newsletter, I want to talk about something that now takes up a significant part of my week: sales coaching.

At LIDOR CONSULTING, we help B2B companies book qualified sales meetings through outbound prospecting, including cold calling. That means reaching people who weren't expecting to hear from us, handling objections, and turning conversations into genuine business opportunities.

I used to spend much of my time making those calls myself. Today, much of my job is helping the people who make them.

That shift taught me something I hadn't anticipated: being good at selling doesn't automatically mean you're good at helping someone else sell.

What surprised me most about becoming a manager

As a sales rep, I had my targets, my prospects, and my phone. I could review what went wrong, adjust my approach, and track my progress. My results were largely in my own hands.

When I became a manager, I assumed I could pass on what had worked for me: how I opened a call, handled an objection, or asked for a meeting.

But an approach that works for one sales rep won't necessarily work for another.

Some people feel comfortable on the phone almost immediately. Others need time to build confidence. Some can start a natural conversation but struggle when a prospect pushes back. Others know their pitch inside out but don't really listen.

Two reps can have the same disappointing numbers for completely different reasons. Telling both to make more calls doesn't necessarily solve either problem.

That's when I began to think differently about sales coaching: before suggesting a fix, I need to understand exactly what's getting in someone's way.

Why cold calling makes those challenges hard to ignore

I believe cold calling is one of the best ways to develop sales skills. It forces you to think on your feet, listen closely, handle rejection, and communicate value in seconds.

But let's be realistic: it can also be repetitive and exhausting.

Picture a morning of voicemails and rejections, followed by a prospect who hangs up after ten seconds. You still have to pick up the phone again with the same energy.

When a rep struggles to book meetings, it's easy to assume they lack motivation or simply aren't making enough calls. Yet the numbers don't always reveal what happens during those conversations.

I realized that when I listened to a call made by one of our reps.

The call that changed my approach

This rep worked hard and knew our offering. He spent plenty of time on the phone, but wasn't booking many meetings.

One day, I listened to one of his calls. The prospect explained that they were already working with another provider.

The rep immediately began explaining the benefits of our solution and why we could do a better job. His pitch was structured, and he knew his arguments.

But he'd skipped one essential question: was the prospect actually happy with their current provider?

He'd heard an objection and rushed to overcome it, without finding out whether there was a real problem to solve.

Afterward, we went through that part of the call together. I suggested trying something simpler: ask a question first, such as, “And are you completely satisfied with the results you're getting today?”

That question doesn't guarantee a meeting, of course. But it gives you a chance to understand the situation before pitching your service.

Over the next few calls, we focused on that one change. Gradually, he spent more time listening and exploring the prospect's answers instead of automatically pushing back against objections.

That's what makes sales call coaching valuable to me: identifying one specific habit, working on it, and seeing whether the conversation improves.

The problem wasn't necessarily how many calls he made. It was what happened at a particular moment during those calls.

What the numbers don't tell you

At LIDOR CONSULTING, we track KPIs: calls made, conversations started, meetings booked, and meetings actually held. We need those numbers to run the business.

But they don't always explain why someone is underperforming.

In this case, the figures showed a rep putting in the work without booking enough meetings. Listening to the call helped me identify what he could do differently.

Now I try to look beyond outcomes and examine what produces them: how we open conversations, how we respond to objections, and whether we ask the questions that uncover real needs.

That also matters for meeting quality. A meeting only creates value for our client if there's a genuine business opportunity behind it. Getting someone to agree to a call isn't enough if we haven't established a potential need.

To me, sales coaching isn't about handing everyone the same script or automatically pushing for more activity. It's about identifying what's holding each person back and helping them improve that specific skill.

That's the biggest change in my role. I used to focus on improving my own results. Now I try to create the conditions for other people to improve theirs.

And I'm still learning how to do it.

Why I'm starting The Sales Diaries

I spend much of my week thinking about these challenges, talking to the team, trying new approaches, and sometimes getting things wrong.

There's no shortage of sales advice out there. Some of it is excellent, but a lot makes selling sound like a matter of following a few simple techniques.

With The Sales Diaries, I want to share what we're actually experiencing at LIDOR CONSULTING: our prospecting methods, outbound strategies, lessons from sales coaching, mistakes, and what we learn from them.

I don't have all the answers. But I think there's value in sharing what happens behind the numbers.

If you're a founder, sales manager, SDR, or just interested in the realities of B2B sales, I hope you'll find something useful here.

What surprised you most when you moved from selling to managing a sales team?

Eliot Nacasch
Founder, LIDOR CONSULTING
The Sales Diaries

Looking for a B2B prospecting agency?

At Lidor Consulting, we prospect for B2B companies. Explore our outsourced business development offers or meet the team.

← All articles
Back to top